AREAS OF KNOWLEDGE:
INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS
This unit explores some challenging questions about Indigenous Knowledge Systems and serves as a vehicle for a gentle introduction to the formal oral presentation.
Frame the actibvity by asking students to revisit the Native Planet photo documentary of the Mantawi people, who live a highly ritualistic, semi-nomadic, hunter gatherer life, relatively isolated on the Mentawai Islands off the coast of Western Sumatra, Indonesia.
One potential threat to the Mantawi culture is the fact that the Islands have some of the very best surfing in the world. Students should visit the high end Australian Surf Travel website, which includes prices. Allow students to express their own conclusions about this “real life example” of globalization.
INDIGENOUS THEMED MINI ORAL PRESENTATIONS
Although students will be tackling a shorter, introductory version of the oral presentation, at this juncture students should see in advance the official presentation guidelines, conceptual digram, grading rubric and TK/PPD document. These are all archived at The Presentation in the Ending TOK section.
The real TOK presentation requires students to identify and explore a knowledge question raised by “a substantive real-life situation.” An essential skill for students is extracting and formulating their own knowledge question from the real-life situation and then applying it back to the real-life situation. The real Presentation can be solo, pairs or groups of three. Ten minutes is allowed per student.
MINI PRESENTATION PROTOCOL:
1. Everyone will work in pairs and the maximim time allocation for the entire presentation will be 8 minutes.
2. Rather than having students formulate their own knowledge question from their real-life situation; we will adopt a reverse, less stringent, approach. Each group selects a different Knowledge Question from the list below and then applies it to a relevant real-life example. Confident students can modify any of the Knowledge Questions on the list or invent one of their own.
3. As with the season of real Presentations that will come later, creative approaches to the presentatiuon are encouraged. Fun should be accopanied with substance.
4. Preparation will include a "mock" TK/PPD document submitted to the teacher as the presentation begins.
5. A schedule of presentation slots should be created that allows some discussion time and a few minutes for public assessment according to the real criteria.
SUGGESTED MENU OF KNOWLEDGE QUESTION THEMES
- To what extent can we say that life in industrialized nations is materially rich, but socially poor, compared to life in traditional societies?
- How effective are the methods used in traditional societies to settle disputes in the absence of police forces and adversarial judicial systems?
- To what extent should we condemn certain traditional societies practices like infanticide and “widow strangling”?
- What if anything can industrialized societies learn about child rearing from traditional societies?
- To what extent is it best to leave the last remaining traditional societies in places like the forests of Amazon and Papua New Guinea well alone?
- To what extent do we romanticize when we refer to people living in traditional societies as “true environmentalists”?
- What is lost when a language dies?
- To what extent are the creation myths of traditional societies fundamentally similar to the written creation texts of the major religions?
- To what extent are globalization and the fusion of cultures progress?
- What can traditional societies teach us about the nature of war?
- To what extent are traditional societies the inevitable product of their geography?
- To what extent can we argue that the collapse or erosion of indigenous societies is only natural?