Extracts from The Case for the Personhood of Gorillas by Francine Patterson & Wendy Gordon. In Paola Cavalieri & Peter Singer (eds.), The Great Ape Project, New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 1993, pp. 58-77.
A. THE “CLEVER HANS” EFFECT
Clever Hans was a German horse that amazed European crowds by apparently stamping out the answers to math problems. Subsequent scientific trials proved that Hans was reacting to the subconscious body cues of his trainer and audience members rather than actually counting. Recognition of the “Clever Hans effect” led to “double blind” testing in psychology experiments.
To what extent is Koko the gorilla’s sign language success free of the “Clever Hans effect”?
B. PERSONHOOD AND INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS
The concept of personhood informs explorations of ethical issues like late-term abortion, animal rights, vegetarianism, euthanasia and the potential rise of artificial intelligence.
- What defines personhood?
- Are human infants and severely mentally impaired people persons?
- Is Koko a person?
- Is an intelligent alien life form a distant planet a person?
- Is your pet dog a person?
- Are the enemy in a bloody foreign war persons?
- Is a fetus in the third trimester a person?
- Is an older person suffering from severe senile dementia―who previously had been living a productive and fulfilling life―a person?
- In the future, self-aware machines may be developed. Can we imagine making the case for personhood for a sentient silicon-based machine?
- Are there any general rules or principles that can guide our thinking about moral status and individual rights?